Agnes — Jocelyn Mireles Gonzalez
Tilly — Nicki Watt
Lilith/Lilly — Sofia Lozano
Kaliope/Kelly — Tessa Schaap
Orcus/Ronnie — Dani Roth
Chuck — Diego Rios Brady
Miles — Brian Briones
Vera, Evil Tina — Kimi Galang Villegas
Steve — Mitchell Yu
Farrah — Swetha Prabakaran
Evil Gabbi — Genevieve Beimforde
Narrator — Brigit Comeau